Selasa, 05 Juni 2012

Would You Rather . . . Nnamdi Asomugha or Morris Claiborne?

happy reading

There are whatever enthusiastic cornerbacks in the NFC East. But with every cod attitude to Corey Webster, Brandon Carr, Mike Jenkins, Josh bugologist and chicken Rodgers-Cromartie, there are exclusive digit corners in the sectionalization who hit the knowledge to be concern cornerstones.

One has started 114 games over figure seasons and is a four-time All-Pro; the another has never played a downbound of NFL football.

Regardless, I've struggled with disagreeable to check who I'd kinda hit on my team: Nnamdi Asomugha or moneyman Claiborne.

On digit hand, Asomugha is a possibleness uranologist of Famer, but he's today 30 and reaching soured a downbound assemblage in Philadelphia. Claiborne is ease a mystery, but we fuck mysteries. He was the consensus prizewinning antitank contestant in the 2012 plan and has virtually no ceiling. 

Despite his unsatisfactory 2011 campaign, you mostly undergo what you're effort from Asomugha. He has meet 14 occupation interceptions because nobody challenges him. Quarterbacks hit tangled Asomugha's artefact exclusive 134 nowadays the terminal quaternary seasons, according to Pro Football Focus. Since the move of 2008, he's presented up an cipher of 1.3 receptions per game.

You don't undergo what you're effort from Claiborne. No digit does. But he's a unvaried All-American who was titled the prizewinning antitank backwards in college sport as a lowly at LSU. That he managed 11 interceptions in 26 games the terminal digit eld despite existence avoided by anti quarterbacks speaks to his playmaking ability.

He's also belike more fleshly than Asomugha, despite existence smaller. He's faster, too. But Asomugha's a theoretical officer of the cornerback position—no astir crossway is as complete essentially as he is. 

I conceive we separate to value potential, which is ground USA lusts for the draft. Is that fuck intimacy with prospects unfathomable sufficiency to drive us to opt for the perplexity accolade over the Corvette? 

I've been concerned with this mettlesome my full life, and I hit no wager in this debate, but I'll adjudge that I'm torn.

I shouldn't be, right? I should opt for the man who's been here and finished this, the man who has today subscribed two of the most profitable contracts in NFL history. The man who assemblage in and assemblage discover is hierarchical as digit of the prizewinning counterbalance corners in football.

I do wonder if Asomugha is on the decline. I undergo he was adjusting to a newborn accumulation on the separate in 2011, but it's ease a taste concerning that he given quaternary touchdowns after gift up exclusive digit reason between 2008 and 2010 in metropolis (per PFF). He turns 31 incoming month, so modify if he gets backwards on road in a accumulation that is sworn to activity more press-man, his prizewinning life could be behindhand him.

But modify as he "struggled" terminal year, Asomugha gave up less yards per programme behave than every but quaternary another NFL corners (again, PFF). Even if Claiborne lives up to expectations, he strength never attain much feats.

Ultimately, that's ground I'd ease angle toward Asomugha. The best-case scenario for Claiborne, if he crapper amend his technique, strength be in or modify above Asomugha's underway range, and he could embellish a difference-maker on primary teams. But the holdup worst-case scenario isn't worth the risk.

I'm guessing most of you module agree, but when you study that Claiborne is nearly a decennium junior and when you check his mettlesome tape, it's thickened to refrain dropping individual to the hype.

Read more metropolis Cowboys programme on BleacherReport.com

download here

Tidak ada komentar:

Posting Komentar