The Sports Illustrated article that was free early this hebdomad titled metropolis Cowboys endeavor back Tony Romo as the ordinal most overrated contestant in the NFL. The balloting was conducted among underway NFL players, 8% of which voted Tony Romo as the most overrated contestant in the mettlesome today. Tim Tebow was irresistibly voted at the top, with 34% of players denotive him atop the list. Romo was equal with Tebow's teammate, Mark Sanchez, in the sort digit spot.
But the players in the NFL got this balloting every wrong.
Tony Romo as the ordinal most overrated contestant in the NFL? Based on what?
The media frenzy close the metropolis Cowboys apiece and every assemblage puts push on whatever contestant with a grapheme on his helmet. The someone speech discover most success the Super Bowl apiece upbringing tent puts modify more push on the players and coaches. You crapper scarce set into ESPN or the NFL Network without chance whatever study of the Cowboys, most of the instance pertaining to their grapheme quarterback.
Digging deeper into the intellection of Romo as existence overrated, it's hornlike to encounter a foundation for that belief.
The definition of overrated is "to evaluate or analyse likewise highly; to overestimate."
To begin my argument, I'd aforementioned to prototypal attain study that Tony Romo didn't become into the 2012 flavour existence regarded as an selected quarterback. Romo was not modify thoughtful to be prizewinning back in his possess division, intellection by nearly every to be beneath New royalty Giants official Eli Manning. You crapper debate most contestant rankings until you are discover of breath, but my saucer is that Romo did not start the flavour with expectations of existence an participant politician or a back that was feat to get the Super Bowl this season.
But the media organisation loves to speech most the Cowboys when they are down. For every awful touchdown transfer Romo throws to Miles Austin or Dez Bryant, you module wager the interception he threw threesome nowadays more ofttimes on the particular reel.
It is quite doable that players around the association are bushed of chance Romo's study mentioned on the domestic environs as ofttimes as it is, or maybe they see his meteoric uprise to honour was premature.
Perhaps if the players had looked beyond the opencast and the particular reels, they would hit seen that Romo strength should hit been voted as digit of the most underrated players in the NFL.
Quarterbacks are judged by some assorted things. Wins, playoff appearances, Super Bowl rings, touchdowns, back ratings and ordinal lodge heroics.
It haw be dirty to watch quarterbacks by playoff wins and Super Bowl rings, but it module ever be digit of the things grouping ingest to watch who is an "elite" quarterback. There is no denying Tony Romo and the Cowboys hit unsuccessful miserably in the playoffs during his term as the starter. Dallas is 1-3 with Romo as the official in the postseason.
But the digit playoff get Romo has gives him the aforementioned sort of playoff wins as diplomatist Cutler and gives him digit more than Matt Ryan (0-3) and Gospels Stafford (0-1).
And if a success playoff achievement is required to meet soured of the "overrated" list, attain trusty to add Peyton Manning (9-10), prince Rivers (3-4) and archangel Vick (2-3) to the list.
Want to study coverall success proportionality as a endeavor quarterback? Romo is 50-33 as a endeavor back finished Week 7 of the 2012 season, gift him a 60% success percentage. That sort is beatific for 8th among astir endeavor quarterbacks. If that sort makes Romo overrated, let's add histrion Brees (59%), Eli Manning (59%) and Matt Schaub (52%) to the list.
So today that we hit wins and losses accounted for, what most his endeavor on the earth apiece week? Romo has tangled for 157 touchdowns in his occupation as a endeavor quarterback, beatific for 1.9 per game. That is the aforementioned sort of touchdowns per mettlesome as blackamoor Brady, Peyton Manning and histrion Brees. Are those quarterbacks thoughtful overrated?
And who throws for inferior touchdowns than that per game? Matt Ryan (1.6), Ben Roethlisberger (1.5) and Joe Flacco (1.3).
There is no denying Tony Romo has a way to obligate a intercommunicate and attain a intense decision that leads to an interception. He has tangled 81 interceptions in his career, beatific for nearly a garner per game. Sounds aforementioned a broad sort (and to Cowboys fans, it is), but it's not as broad as the drawing of Eli Manning (1.1), environmentalist linksman (1.1) and Gospels Stafford (1.2).
In 1971, an chief of the Pro Football uranologist of Fame, Don Smith, led a primary NGO that created the back footer judgement grouping that is currently used. The judgement is supported on quaternary statistical categories: termination percentage, yards per attempt, proportionality of touchdowns and proportionality of interceptions.
When you countenance at occupation ratings for astir quarterbacks, ballplayer composer is atop the itemize with a 104.7 occupation rating, followed by blackamoor moneyman at 96.4. And the back with the ordinal maximal occupation judgement is Tony Romo at 95.9. If Romo is overrated, what most the guys beneath him on the list, aforementioned Peyton Manning (95.2), prince Rivers (94.9), histrion Brees (94.2) or Matt Ryan (89.5)?
Numbers cannot ever verify the whole programme of a contestant or the continuance of the contestant to his team. You crapper countenance at nearly whatever individualist sort and increase a player's value, or you crapper countenance at a assorted datum to render him as worthless.
The lowermost distinction is this: Tony Romo ranks nearby the crowning of whatever statistical collection among astir quarterbacks, ofttimes nowadays higher than players widely thoughtful to be a such meliorate back than Romo.
Elite? Maybe not. Overrated? Absolutely not, and the drawing establish it.
Read more metropolis Cowboys programme on BleacherReport.com
Custom HTML Bawah
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar